ARCHIVEInstacart Brings the Big Game Home With We're Here
How Instacart 's 'We're Here' Redefined Game Day Delivery at Super Bowl LIX Instacart's 'We're...
Etsy Gift Mode Reframes Big Game Advertising as a Gifting Invitation
Etsy's Gift Mode campaign is the brand's first-ever Big Game commercial, created by Orchard and aired in the United States on February 11, 2024, introducing an AI-and-human-curated gifting tool through the rallying message "Don't panic. Gift easy with Etsy."
Etsy debuted Gift Mode as a product and a campaign simultaneously, using the Super Bowl as the launchpad for a feature that combines machine learning, artificial intelligence, and OpenAI's GPT-4 technology with human editorial curation to surface personalised gift recommendations. The campaign was announced on February 1, 2024, ten days before the spot aired, giving the brand a runway to build anticipation across the United States. Orchard, the creative agency appointed to Etsy's account in June 2023 after replacing 72andSunny New York, as reported by Muse by Clios, delivered the campaign roughly eight months after taking the brief. The single film asset carries all the narrative weight of the launch, positioning Etsy as the antidote to the stress that accompanies high-stakes gift shopping. According to Etsy's own research, 71 percent of Americans reported feeling anxious about giving gifts, according to MediaPost, a figure that gave the campaign its emotional architecture. The geographic scope extended to the United Kingdom as well, as reported by Mobile Marketing Magazine, though the Super Bowl broadcast anchored the campaign firmly in the US market. With a Clapboard Score of 67 out of 100, Gift Mode represents a competent and strategically coherent entry into Big Game advertising, one that trades spectacle for utility and positions eCommerce as an emotional service rather than a transactional channel.
Etsy identified a specific and underserved emotional need in the United States eCommerce market. The strategic premise of Gift Mode rests on a documented consumer tension: gifting is a frequent, high-frequency behaviour that most shoppers find stressful rather than enjoyable. According to MediaPost, Etsy's internal research found that 71 percent of Americans felt anxious about giving gifts, a statistic that provided both the creative brief and the product rationale in one move. Rather than competing on price or speed — the dominant axes on which Amazon and Walmart contest the US retail services market — Etsy chose to compete on emotional relief and personalisation, territories where its marketplace of unique, independent-seller goods holds a structural advantage.
The timing of the campaign was deliberate and precise. The Super Bowl represents one of the highest-reach media moments in the United States each year, and February sits adjacent to Valentine's Day, one of the most gift-intensive occasions in the retail calendar. By launching Gift Mode at the intersection of these two moments, Etsy positioned itself as top-of-mind for US consumers entering a gifting decision in real time. The campaign's strategic logic extended to the product itself: Gift Mode uses AI-generated recommendations layered with human curation, a combination that signals both technological sophistication and the artisanal warmth that differentiates Etsy from impersonal algorithmic retailers. According to Investors Etsy, approximately 74 percent of Etsy marketplace gross merchandise sales in 2024 came from US buyers, confirming that the United States remains the brand's core commercial territory and the right market in which to make a large-scale brand statement. Orchard's strategic framing of the campaign as a utility launch rather than a pure awareness play gave it a durable shelf life beyond the single broadcast moment.
Director Andreas Nilsson of Biscuit Filmworks led the production of the Gift Mode film. Nilsson, whose work frequently deploys heightened absurdist comedy to defuse tension, was a precise fit for a brief that needed to make anxiety feel immediately recognisable and then resolve it without condescension. Chief Creative Officer David Kolbusz of Orchard oversaw the creative direction, with Creative Director Conor Dooley and Art Director Serban Porupca shaping the visual and tonal execution. Production Designer Peter Grant built the physical world of the spot, while Executive Producer Holly Vega and US Head of Production Sean Moody managed delivery. US Managing Director Shawn Lacy oversaw the agency-side relationship, as documented by LBBonline.
The production filmed in Bucharest, Romania, in December 2023, according to LBBonline, a logistical choice that allowed the team to control production costs while maintaining the visual quality expected of a Super Bowl commercial in the US market. The film's creative mechanism is built around a contrast structure: the opening establishes the chaotic, paralysing experience of trying to find a meaningful gift, and the second half demonstrates how Gift Mode dissolves that paralysis. The tone is warm rather than satirical, reassuring rather than aspirational. This was a deliberate departure from the high-concept, heavily produced spectacles that dominate Super Bowl Commercials, and it was a strategic one. By grounding the spot in a relatable domestic register, Orchard ensured the message would translate cleanly to US audiences encountering it in a noisy, distracted viewing environment. The choice to anchor the campaign in a single film asset, as noted by the campaign record, concentrated creative investment rather than diffusing it across a fragmented media mix, a discipline that strengthened message clarity.
The Gift Mode film accumulated more than 421,000 views and 1,047 likes on YouTube, with 172 comments recorded against the asset, as documented in the campaign record. These figures reflect organic engagement following the Super Bowl broadcast and represent a measurable indicator of post-air interest in the United States, though they do not constitute a comprehensive performance disclosure. No verified campaign-level performance data, including sales uplift, Gift Mode feature adoption rates, or return on advertising spend, is publicly available for this campaign.
The broader commercial context, however, provides meaningful structural evidence of Etsy's market position at the time of the campaign. According to investors.etsy.com, the Etsy marketplace generated approximately 10.9 billion dollars in gross merchandise sales in 2024, with the consolidated Etsy, Inc. network — encompassing Etsy, Reverb, and Depop — reaching 12.6 billion dollars in GMS for the same year. The marketplace connected 89.6 million active buyers with 5.6 million active sellers in 2024, according to investors.etsy.com, though active buyer numbers declined 3 percent year-over-year during the same period, also per investors.etsy.com. This context frames Gift Mode not merely as an awareness campaign but as a strategic response to a retention and engagement challenge in the US eCommerce market. By introducing a product feature with genuine utility at the highest-reach media moment available in the United States, Etsy gave the campaign structural durability beyond a single broadcast. The Clapboard Score of 67 out of 100 reflects a campaign that executes its stated objectives with competence and strategic clarity, while stopping short of the creative distinctiveness that would place it among the most memorable Super Bowl Commercials of 2024.
Etsy's Gift Mode campaign is the brand's first-ever Super Bowl commercial, created by Orchard and aired in the United States on February 11, 2024. It introduced an AI-and-human-curated gifting feature with the message "Don't panic. Gift easy with Etsy," targeting US consumers feeling anxious about finding meaningful gifts.
Orchard created the Etsy Gift Mode campaign. Orchard was appointed as Etsy's creative agency in June 2023, replacing 72andSunny New York, as reported by Muse by Clios. Gift Mode launched approximately eight months after that appointment and marked Orchard's first major campaign for the brand in the United States.
Andreas Nilsson of Biscuit Filmworks directed the Etsy Gift Mode film. Nilsson worked under Chief Creative Officer David Kolbusz and Creative Director Conor Dooley at Orchard. The spot was filmed in Bucharest, Romania, in December 2023, according to LBBonline, before its US broadcast during Super Bowl 2024.
Etsy's Gift Mode combines machine learning, artificial intelligence, and OpenAI's GPT-4 technology with human editorial curation, according to MediaPost. The feature generates personalised gift recommendations from Etsy's marketplace. At the time of the campaign launch, the marketplace listed more than 100 million items across approximately 7 million sellers, as reported by MediaPost.
Etsy chose the Super Bowl because it is the highest-reach media moment in the United States, and February falls adjacent to Valentine's Day, a peak gifting occasion. According to Etsy's internal research cited by MediaPost, 71 percent of Americans felt anxious about giving gifts, making the timing strategically aligned with an active consumer need.
Etsy's Gift Mode campaign received a Clapboard Score of 67 out of 100. The score reflects a campaign that meets its strategic objectives with clarity and executes a coherent eCommerce gifting narrative for the US market, while not reaching the creative distinctiveness of the most awarded Super Bowl Commercials of 2024.
.webp)
Creative Collaboration Platform: The Backbone of Modern Creative WorkWhat is a creative collaboration platform?Clapboard defines a creative collaboration platform as the operational core for today’s distributed creative teams. This is not a collection of digital collaboration tools stitched together; Clapboard’s system
Understanding the Creative Production MarketplaceWhat is a Creative Production Marketplace?Clapboard defines a creative production marketplace as a structured ecosystem where brands, agencies, and production talent converge to execute video, advertising, and branded content at scale. Unlike the legacy agency or freelanREAD FULL ARTICLE
The Urgent Need for a Creative Production Operating SystemWhy Traditional Creative Production Models Break DownClapboard sees the creative production landscape shifting under pressure. Content velocity is no longer a buzzword—it’s a mandate. Modern advertising demands relentless output across dozens of channels, each wREAD FULL ARTICLE
