ARCHIVELidl Sweden Turns Fresh Produce Into a Samurai Spectacle
How Lidl Sweden Used Samurai Sword Spectacle to Reframe Fresh Fruit in Retail Lidl's "Fruit Ninja"...
ALDI Australia Challenges Supermarket Discounting With Good Different
ALDI Australia's 'Good Different – Don't Drown In One-off Discounts' is a 2019 film campaign created by BMF Sydney that positions ALDI's everyday low-price model as a structural alternative to the temporary discount cycles that define mainstream Australian supermarket retail.
The campaign launched in February and March 2019, extending the 'Good Different' platform that BMF had first built for ALDI in May 2017. Where the original platform established ALDI as a proudly distinct kind of retailer in the Australian market, this 2019 execution sharpened that proposition into a pointed critique. The specific target is the promotional mechanics of ALDI's major competitors — the rotating, category-specific discounts that require shoppers to track sales windows, stockpile selectively, and essentially work to save money. ALDI's counterargument, embedded in the campaign's core line, is that its everyday low prices remove that labour entirely.
In Australia, the grocery retail sector is dominated by a duopoly in which Woolworths and Coles collectively hold the majority of market share, according to reporting by Inside Retail Australia. ALDI operates as a significant challenger in this environment, and the 'Good Different' platform is the strategic instrument through which it has consistently articulated that challenger identity. The 2019 film extends that identity with a tone that is direct, slightly absurdist, and confident — qualities consistent with BMF's broader creative approach for the brand.
The campaign ran across television, out-of-home, online, social, in-store and catalogue channels, according to documentation on Ads of the World, giving the message broad market penetration across the Australian retail advertising landscape. Paul Coles, General Manager of ALDI, commented in The Drum on February 18, 2019: 'The beauty of Aldi's everyday low prices is that you'll save money no matter what you buy – it certainly takes the stress out of keeping your grocery bill down. Plus, you'll avoid ending up with a cupboard full of half-price tuna.' That last image — the cupboard of unwanted discounted goods — is the campaign's sharpest insight rendered in plain speech. Clapboard rates this campaign 63 out of 100.
ALDI's everyday low-price model represents a structurally different retail proposition. It does not require promotional events to generate traffic, and it does not depend on category-specific deals to communicate value. The 'Good Different – Don't Drown In One-off Discounts' campaign makes that structural difference legible to Australian grocery shoppers by naming the alternative — the one-off discount — and framing it as a burden rather than a benefit.
The consumer insight is precise. Promotional pricing in Australian supermarkets tends to concentrate savings in specific categories during specific windows, rewarding attentive shoppers and penalising those who shop habitually or across a broad basket. ALDI's model, by contrast, delivers savings on every item in every visit. BMF's strategy, led by executive planning director Christina Aventi and strategic planner Kellie Box, translates this operational reality into an emotional register: relief, simplicity, and a mild but clear contempt for the complexity that competitors impose on shoppers.
The competitive context in Australia at the time of the campaign's release was significant. Woolworths and Coles, ALDI's two principal competitors in the Australian grocery market, both operate promotional programmes that cycle discounts through their ranges on a weekly basis, a model that Inside Retail Australia has documented as central to their customer retention strategies. Against this backdrop, ALDI's refusal to participate in promotional cycling is not merely a cost-structure decision — it is a positioning statement. The 2019 campaign converts that statement into an active argument rather than a passive brand attribute. According to Bain, in summer 2018 ALDI held more than three percent of grocery spending in six of eight markets studied globally, with share gains in most of those markets over the preceding two years, suggesting that the underlying value proposition was resonating with shoppers across multiple geographies, including Australia.
The creative execution of 'Good Different – Don't Drown In One-off Discounts' is built around the film medium. The campaign's single media asset uses the visual language of consumer frustration — the experience of navigating promotional complexity — and renders it with the kind of dry, slightly surreal humour that Australian retail advertising has used effectively to cut through category noise.
The creative team at BMF Sydney was led by executive creative director Alex Derwin. Creative directors David Fraser and Dantie Van Der Merwe shaped the campaign's tone and structure. Copywriters Justin Butler and Lisa Down and art director Simon Koay completed the core creative group, according to campaign documentation published on Ads of the World and Campaign Brief. The campaign was directed by Jeff Low, a detail confirmed in production records cited by Campaign Brief, whose ability to balance comic timing with a clear argumentative through-line is visible in the finished work.
The tone of the film is consistent with the broader 'Good Different' platform established in 2017. That platform had always positioned ALDI's difference as something to be celebrated rather than explained away — a quality that requires creative confidence to sustain across multiple executions. The 2019 film maintains that confidence while adding a more combative edge, one appropriate to a proposition that is explicitly naming and rejecting a competitor behaviour. The visual metaphor of drowning — referenced directly in the campaign's title — gives the creative team a physical, absurdist image to work with, grounding an abstract pricing argument in a concrete, memorable scene. Coverage of the campaign's launch appeared in Shots and The Drum on February 18, 2019, indicating meaningful trade-press interest in the execution at the time of release.
The 'Good Different – Don't Drown In One-off Discounts' execution sits within a broader platform whose commercial outcomes are documented. No verified award record — at Cannes Lions, the Effies, One Show, D&AD, Clio, or the Webbys — has been established specifically for this 2019 execution, according to available public records. However, the 'Good Different' platform as a whole is a different matter.
According to WARC, which lists a case study titled 'Aldi: Good Different' as a campaign outcomes report, the platform delivered a thirty-two percent increase in sales growth. That figure is attributed to the platform across its operational period, not isolated to the 2019 film. The broader 'Good Different' platform also won Grand Effie recognition, along with Gold in the Food and Beverage category and Silver for ROI, according to available award records, though direct attribution of those wins to the 'Don't Drown In One-off Discounts' execution has not been publicly established.
The structural effectiveness of the 2019 campaign is grounded in its argumentative clarity. It does not ask shoppers to feel warmly toward ALDI — it asks them to recognise a friction in their current shopping behaviour and attribute its removal to ALDI's model. That is a direct and measurable ask, and one well-suited to driving both brand consideration and basket conversion in the competitive Australian grocery market. Deloitte's FY2017 global retailer ranking placed ALDI at approximately ninety-eight point three billion US dollars in revenue, ranking it eighth among listed global retailers, according to Deloitte, a scale that supports the investment required to sustain a platform of this ambition across the Australian market.
'Don't Drown In One-off Discounts' is a 2019 Australian film campaign created by BMF Sydney for ALDI. It extends the 'Good Different' platform by arguing that ALDI's everyday low prices spare shoppers the complexity of competitor discount cycles. The campaign ran across television, out-of-home, online, social, in-store and catalogue channels.
Jeff Low directed the 2019 'Don't Drown In One-off Discounts' film for ALDI Australia. The campaign was created by BMF Sydney, with executive creative director Alex Derwin leading the creative team alongside creative directors David Fraser and Dantie Van Der Merwe, copywriters Justin Butler and Lisa Down, and art director Simon Koay.
According to WARC, the 'Good Different' platform delivered a thirty-two percent increase in sales growth for ALDI Australia. The platform also won Grand Effie recognition, including Gold in Food and Beverage and Silver for ROI, according to available award records. Direct attribution of these results to the 2019 execution has not been publicly confirmed.
BMF Sydney's creative team included executive creative director Alex Derwin, creative directors David Fraser and Dantie Van Der Merwe, copywriters Justin Butler and Lisa Down, and art director Simon Koay. Planning was led by executive planning director Christina Aventi and strategic planner Kellie Box, according to documentation on Ads of the World.
The campaign positions ALDI's everyday low-price model as structurally simpler than the promotional discount cycles operated by Woolworths and Coles, ALDI's two principal competitors in the Australian grocery market. Rather than matching competitor promotions, the 2019 film frames promotional complexity itself as the problem that ALDI's model solves for shoppers.
The campaign launched in February 2019, with coverage appearing in Shots and The Drum on February 18, 2019. It was formally published in the Australian market in March 2019. The execution is part of the broader 'Good Different' platform that BMF first developed for ALDI Australia in May 2017.
.webp)
Creative Collaboration Platform: The Backbone of Modern Creative WorkWhat is a creative collaboration platform?Clapboard defines a creative collaboration platform as the operational core for today’s distributed creative teams. This is not a collection of digital collaboration tools stitched together; Clapboard’s system
Understanding the Creative Production MarketplaceWhat is a Creative Production Marketplace?Clapboard defines a creative production marketplace as a structured ecosystem where brands, agencies, and production talent converge to execute video, advertising, and branded content at scale. Unlike the legacy agency or freelanREAD FULL ARTICLE
The Urgent Need for a Creative Production Operating SystemWhy Traditional Creative Production Models Break DownClapboard sees the creative production landscape shifting under pressure. Content velocity is no longer a buzzword—it’s a mandate. Modern advertising demands relentless output across dozens of channels, each wREAD FULL ARTICLE
